It was so effective that it was almost difficult to tell where my real hairs ended and where the pencil marks began. The end result? A defined, natural-looking brow that made it look like I was ...

Along with mascara, filling in my brows with an eyebrow pencil is a non-negotiable for me, even on no makeup days. It's taken years to find the best brow pencil for me and my eyebrows, which is ...

The rarely-on-sale celeb favorite, now just $17, comes in a dozen colors and easily creates a natural look, fans say.