After the victory and celebrations, Williams continued his fun on social media with a post. It appeared his message was aimed at Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers. Williams signed with the Jets this offseason after a serious injury in 2023. That held him back, then he really fell out of favor in New York when Rodgers was critical of him.

After the New York Jets fell to the Buffalo Bills 23-20 in Week 6, Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers called out one of his wide receivers for not running the correct route on an interception. He told reporters that Williams was supposed to stay on the "red line" on the practice field, which is five yards from the sideline.

Following his debut with the Pittsburgh Steelers in the 2024 NFL season, Mike Williams sent a surprising taunting message to former New York Jets teammate Aaron Rodgers.